GTG Celebrates Win Over Applera


By Graeme O'Neill Australian Biotechnology News

An elated Dr Mervyn Jacobson, CEO of Genetic Technologies, flew back to Melbourne from San Francisco Friday after slaying his company's most reluctant dragon, giant US rival Applera.

After an exhausting mediation session lasting from 9am on December 8 to 3am on December 9, Applera's lawyers agreed to pay an undisclosed fee to license GTG's patented 'junk DNA' gene-testing technology, one of the broadest patents ever issued in the recombinant DNA technology field, and the only US patent on the use of non-coding DNA markers for gene testing.

The commercial terms of the settlement remain confidential, but according an announcement to GTG shareholders today, GTG and Applera have executed several binding agreements, including a final settlement agreement, a licence agreement, and a supply agreement, before Judge Joseph Spero, of the US District Court of Northern California.

The two parties will also move to dismiss all claims and counterclaims in their legal action before Judge Phillis Hamilton, in the same jurisdiction.

Lone Holdout
GTG originally sued Applera, and two other US gene testing companies, Novelo and Covance, in March 2003, for refusing to take licences and pay royalties on its patented technologies. Novelo and Covance both submitted and took licences in November 2004, leaving Applera -- the largest gene-testing company in the US -- as the lone holdout.

The first sign of a negotiated settlement came on October 13 this year, when the parties executed a confidential term sheet and agreed to further negotiations before Judge Spero.

Applera and GTG were originally to have reached a negotiated settlement on November 9, but after three extensions, finally settled on December 9.

Jacobson today described the mediation process as "quite strenuous".

"But standing back and looking at it from 38,000 feet, it's a very significant result," he said. "Since GTG launched its licensing program three years ago, we've had people challenging our right to charge licence fees, or telling us to go to hell and sue us.

"It's been constant -- even when we were pursuing licences, there has always been some company or group challenging us, so we've been continually distracted with ongoing legal battles. But this is the end of the seventh and final battle.

"Today, with the Applera matter settled, nobody in the world is challenging our patents. For a little Australian company to file a lawsuit against Applera, and have the resources to see it through, and bear the associated legal costs for three years, is obviously very significant."

Turning Point
Jacobson said the research community and commercial gene-testing companies around the world had been watching the case, and would see it as a turning point.

"Lots of people have hidden behind Applera, believed that time was on their side, if Applera could continue to obstruct us, and invalidate our patents -- or simply wait us out," he said. "Now that Applera has come to an agreement with us, they have nowhere to hide."

Jacobson warned that companies that had delayed taking a licence from GTG were now exposed. "The nature of the settlement may justify us repricing," he said. "Our own view on what the patents are worth may need to be reexamined.

"I am now setting my sights on hundreds of targets who, in our view, already owe substantial amounts for past activities, and will owe us more for future activities."

Win for Australian Biotech
Jacobson characterised the win as "a great victory for Australia's biotechnology industry too."

"In human terms, this is a case of the little guy taking on a giant and prevailing," he said. "So we have to assume that the little guy had something of great value -- that's now clearly established.

"So much has been written about Australian companies' [lack of success] on the world scene, now here is an Australian company that has gone onto the world stage seven times and won -- and we've not sued anybody within Australia."

Click here to login and leave a comment.  

0 Comments

Add Comment

Text Only 2000 character limit

Page 1 of 1

White Papers & Special Reports

HP white paper image
Extreme Storage Knowledge Center
Sponsored by HP

Visit HP’s Extreme Storage Knowledge Center to find informative, complimentary white papers, case studies, videos, product information and more.  Brief overview of topics:

  • The challenges of unstructured storage and how to manage both cost-effectively and efficiently
  • Company case studies of data storage challenges that translate across pharmaceutical and biotech companies today
  • Systems that manage vast amounts of data with simple deployment, unified management, and extreme scalability at an exceptionally low price per terabyte
  • Life sciences data management; viable solutions for small and large companies to manage growing storage demands
  • Take our virtual product tour and see our storage unit from inside out


Coupa white paper 92
10 Secrets to Recession-Proof Your Business
Sponsored by Coupa


Read this white paper to discover 10 strategies smart companies deploy to recession-proof their business.
Leaders generally face hard choices on how to mange a company during an economic downturn and
behave in one of three ways:
1) “The ostrich” - Preserve the status quo/hope for the best
2) “The bull in the china shop” - Blindly cut expenses across the board
3) “The fox” - Use the downturn to make your business more effective and position it for future growth

Learn how to behave “like a fox” and use a recession as a means to pounce on emerging trends.



SGI BriefingON image
High-Performance Computing in Life Science & Education
Sponsored by SGI and Intel
The varied collection of Bio-IT World articles and insights assembled in this BriefingON examine key trends in HPC infrastructure and how researchers are putting their best computational resources to use. Provided here are stories and lessons around the effective use of high performance computing in life science. Download the BriefingON.


Life Science Webcasts & Podcasts

Medidata Solutions

Rising Clinical Trial Delays and Costs - Addressing the Cause, Not the Symptoms 

medidata podcastProtocol complexity is taking a toll on clinical study speed and efficiency: increasingly complicated and ambitious protocols are not only burdening sites and study volunteers but are also prolonging trials and increasing expenses. In response, sponsors have turned to global study placement, restructured site relationships and new site management practices, but the problem remains.

This podcast will discuss:

  • Why these responses address only the symptoms, not the underlying cause, of rising clinical trial delays and costs.
  • Results of a recent joint Tufts University / Medidata Solutions study.
  • New metrics benchmarking protocol design trends.
  • Systematic protocol design improvements and why they are essential to clinical trial performance excellence.

Speakers: Ken Getz, Senior Research Fellow at the Tufts Center for the Study of Drug Development, and Ed Seguine, General Manager, Trial Planning Solutions at Medidata.

Download Now 



More Podcasts

Job Openings

Manager, Scientific Computing & Programming
Lead SAIC-Frederick, Inc.’s Bioinformatics & Analysis Group in developing & maintaining informatics pipelines for generation/analysis of dense genotyping & next-generation sequencing data. Required:  MS or equiv.  5 yrs related experience.  Knowledge of programming/software development, high performance computing, bioinformatics, project management. Visit www.saic-frederick.com - #130019.

For reprints and/or copyright permission, please contact The YGS Group, 1808 Colonial Village Lane, Lancaster, PA;

(717) 399-1900 ext. 125, or via email to Ashley.Zander@theYGSgroup.com.